Choose 1 of the following questions. Answer in 200 words or more- but be concise.
1. Examine “Letter 1,” and explain Robert Walton’s feelings about and motivations for going beyond the boundaries of what is known. Please use at least two text references in the course of your answer. Do you believe humans should risk their lives and those of other for exploration?
2. A. Examine “Letter 2” and explain Walton’s need for a companion. Use at least one quote to explain his rationale. B. In your opinion, is companionship one of life’s necessities? Explain your answer.
3. Examine “Letter 4” and explain your impressions of the stranger found and rescued by Robert Walton. Refer to at least three details about the stranger.
4. Explain how “Letter 4” addresses both the ideas of ambition and companionship. Use at least 2 quotes in the course of your answer.
Take a moment to review Romanticism:
http://www.slideshare.net/wiglaf12/the-romantic-era-17981832-presentation
1. Examine “Letter 1,” and explain Robert Walton’s feelings about and motivations for going beyond the boundaries of what is known. Please use at least two text references in the course of your answer. Do you believe humans should risk their lives and those of other for exploration?
2. A. Examine “Letter 2” and explain Walton’s need for a companion. Use at least one quote to explain his rationale. B. In your opinion, is companionship one of life’s necessities? Explain your answer.
3. Examine “Letter 4” and explain your impressions of the stranger found and rescued by Robert Walton. Refer to at least three details about the stranger.
4. Explain how “Letter 4” addresses both the ideas of ambition and companionship. Use at least 2 quotes in the course of your answer.
Take a moment to review Romanticism:
http://www.slideshare.net/wiglaf12/the-romantic-era-17981832-presentation
question #2:
ReplyDeleteIn Letter 2, Walton sends a letter to his sister explaining that he found a crew that could help him on his voyage for exploration. In the letter Walton explains that he would like to have a companion, a friend. Walton says “I have no friend, Margaret: when I am glowing with the enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy; if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavour to sustain me in dejection. I shall commit my thoughts to paper, it is true; but that is a poor medium for the communication of feeling. I desire the company of a man who could sympathise with me; whose eyes would reply to mine. You may deem me romantic, my dear sister, but I bitterly feel the want of a friend. I have no one near me, gentle yet courageous, possessed of a cultivated as well as of a capacious mind, whose tastes are like my own, to approve or amend my plans.” Walton main reason for wanting a friend is that he wants someone that approve of his plan. I agree with Walton that he need a companion for him to feel happier because I think companionship is one of life’s necessities. I learned in life that god created man and with man god created a companion so that man wouldn’t feel alone on earth. This is why I believe companionship is a life’s necessities because without companionship man wouldn’t be able to live a life by itself. We need a companion to talk about what we feel, about what we like and about our fear. Companionship is an important part in life because not only do human have companionship but also most animal in the animal kingdom. We have dauphins, dogs, cats, birds, and even insect have companionship. This is why I strongly agree that companionship is one of life’s necessities.
Great point. Another thing to consider though, is how despite how Walton is at this point, it was his choice in the first place to go out at sea. You think that this was a blind mistake on his part or a consequence of his ambition?
DeleteCJ, I think you're on to something about his lack of a friend for approving his decisions, but also where I disagree is where your emphasis lies. I believe too that companionship is nonetheless a necessity, however for the sake of survival? Companionship does certainly increase chances of survival, like the animal kingdom, but in the life of Man, companions are most useful in the support of mostly mental and emotional support. I believe it's empathy that Walton wanted most.
Deletei strongly agree with you when you stated that without companionship man wouldn't be able to live by itself as it would be trapped in its own thoughts and emotions. You also made a vivid point when pointing out that god created companionship so one won't feel alone on this earth.
DeleteI agree with you on this point of man needing companionship but have you thought about how this idea is contradictory throughout the novel? The monster also tries to gain some companionship in order to not be all alone. All though victor does not want to give him anyone that can relate to him and be around him. Could that lack of companionship be a justification for the monsters actions?
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete[Q4]
ReplyDeleteIn the fourth letter that Robert writes to his sister, he explains how, while his ship had been trapped in ice, he and his crew meet Victor Frankenstein. In the course of these events, Robert becomes more and more intrigued in Victor, thus giving the idea of camaraderie. However, I believe that this idea of companionship is false. In the letter, he explains to Margaret how he found a "brother of [his] heart." However, as Robert continues to write about him, it becomes more apparent that he's less interested in him as a person, but rather, is more interested in the idea of him. Although he does include some of his interactions with Victor, Robert's more vivid descriptions are of how he sees Victor's character, focusing on the dichotomy between the "noble" character Robert has in his mind about Victor, a characteristic that's constantly noted within the letter, and the wreck Victor truly is. In previous letters, it's shown that Robert had failed in his ambition to become a writer. Because of this, it can be assumed that the only reason Robert is "interested" in Victor is because he has a chance to return to his initial ambition. This is subtly shown when Robert describes how Victor speaks: "his words are culled with the choicest art, yet they flow with rapidity and unparalleled eloquence." In a way, it could be argued that Robert is somewhat jealous of Victor, but still wants to use him. In conclusion, in a book that condemns the idea of being overly ambitious, it begins with a man feigning companionship with another to use him for his own ambition.
I agree with you, as there are many hints suggesting that Walton may only be interested in Victor's similar ambition, however, I do believe there is still a potential empathy existent in Walton towards Victor. It's this compassion and level of companionship that allows Walton to hear someone out on their warning of the dangers of such a wanderer's life, otherwise Walton's ambition would've had Victor rebuked?
Deletegreet points! i do agree with you that Walton is intrigued by the ideal of Victor as he is desperate for a friend. However, how would you suggest that Walton is jealous of Victor?
DeleteI like how you summarized in the beginning to give some short info. I do agree with every point you made,because Walton is intrigued. I would also like to know how or what part quote says that Walton is jealous of Victor, when Walton shared his lifestory with victor?
DeleteTo begin, Esteban, I do agree that Walton has somewhat of an empathy towards Victor. However, I do not believe that Walton truly "hears Victor out" in his warning. As for Miranda and Stacy's questions , Walton describes how he failed in his attempts to become a writer. The way how Walton describes Victor's words as "unparalleled", as shown in the quote above, shows that Walton greatly respects Victor's skill. Earlier, Walton describes how bad his own writing was to his sister. This, in contrast, with Victor's superior articulation could be an indication of insecurity. Thus, it could be "argued" that it's jealousy. Consider that the stereotypical man would never want to directly state his insecurity, especially to his own sister.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteQuestion 3:
ReplyDeleteAs soon as Victor Frankenstein was found and rescued by Robert Walton, there was an instant fixation on the man. The crew was interested to see what Dr. Frankenstein was doing when he was rescued, while Walton was intrigued due to his lack in companionship. As the words, “ ‘Before I board your vessel.. Will you have the kindness inform me whether if you are bound?’ ” escaped the stranger's mouth and he agreed to come on board, he seemed to have a connection with Walton and left the crew astonished. Every living thing on the ship wanted to know more about the man on the sled and who was the man that we was so desperately chasing.An impression that the stranger had on me was that he was hiding a secret. He kept to himself, even when he was healed and could travel. The crew members were not able to speak to him,even though they just had basic questions, such as : where had he come from, what was he doing, and what was his plan. It was very peculiar when the only person he had decided to explain to was Robert Walton, this led to an instantaneous connection . As Dr. Victor Frankenstein started to answer questions, his character become more driven and dark. Even though his character is parallel to Walton’s, he has a dark aura about him. Victor’s story is being told by Robert Walton, this causes the mood and tone to be distorted, yet the overall feeling of being isolated by your work in a castle and robbing graves in the night shows how driven he was. No matter what got in his way, Victor Frankenstein was going to achieve his goal, regardless how morally wrong it may be.
I don't necessarily believe that Victor was hiding anything to Walton, but rather just the crew. Albeit, everyone on the ship marveled as this stranger boarded their vessel, however it is only Walton who makes a connection with Victor. Both had a unique fascination for exploring the unknown, both were deadlocked in achieving glory, but both lacked the feeling of compassion from others, obviously Walton had his crew and Victor had family back home, however when they were alone with themselves doing what each did best, they felt solitude. As words were never immediately spoken, the very actions of compassion towards one another opened up Victor to Walton. This is big because it's not every day you boast or warn of re-animating the dead.
DeleteI completely agree with you. Victor was immediately given solicitude once he boarded the ship, and as time passed by, Victor and Walton’s friendship developed. Walton saw Victor as a companion who shared not only the same interests, but also the same qualities. Both characters suffer from their own excessive pride; Walton’s purpose for exploring the North Pole was because he wants to be recognized for exploring a territory that no man has ever been to, and Victor hoped for the same reason.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteQuestion 1:
ReplyDeleteI believe that Walton is unrelenting and boldly determined for the exploration of the undiscovered, with the natural curiosity that first drew our ancestors to explore the unknown in every area, and because of that curiosity and exploration, we are more advanced in literally every area of application! As for his motives, Walton is drawn in between a 50/50 of what he hopes to get out the voyage. On one hand, he seeks to benefit mankind with this discovery, in hopes that it’ll help them all with the discovery of this proclaimed passage to the pole. In his words to his own dear sister, “you cannot contest the inestimable benefit which I shall confer on all mankind to the last generation, by discovering a passage near the pole to those countries”. However, the other hand shows that he has interest in gaining honor and glory for his discoveries. Who wouldn’t want at least some credit right? To be marked down along with other great discoverers of new ideas or places! As Walton says, “I imagined that I also might obtain a niche in the temple where the names of Homer and Shakespeare are consecrated.” To be along the greats, the ones history recalled best, that was what Walton was after. Not only because the praise that came with their achievements, but most importantly they were almost never forgotten. Human beings, aside from the greed of similar glory, should also take risks when it comes to the exploration of the possible infinite! Had we never taken risks, would we have ever set foot on the moon? Would we have ever made cures or treatments for diseases like Measles? It is the risk of life that the best and the worst can come.
In letter 1, Robert Walton is obviously shown to be delighted to be going on this voyage as shown in the quote, “These reflections have dispelled the agitation with which I began my letter, and I feel my heart glow with enthusiasm.” Walton is being motivated to take this journey in order to help mankind, consequently he has filled his head will illusions of helping the world by discovering a passage near the pole which has let him become a bit too ambitious. However, he also shows that he is aware of the dangers posed during his voyage. This can be illustrated in the quote “These are my enticements, and they are sufficient to conquer all fear of danger or death…” Walton does not seem to care that his life could be at risk and that really shows how passionate and dedicated he is to his work. I believe humans should risk their lives for exploration only if they choose to, no one should be forcibly taken exploring. Exploring is worth dying for if there is an opportunity to expand our knowledge, our entire country was discovered by exploring. Our world cannot progress without those willing to give their lives in order to better ours.
ReplyDeleteRobert Walton primarily begins his letter by “How slowly the time passes here, encompassed as I am by frost and snow!” to demonstrate not only his loneliness, but also his desperate desire for a companion. He proudly tells his sister about his success on finding a ship and a crew that will assist him throughout his journey. Walton also confesses to her about the loneliness he feels, “when I am glowing with the enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy; if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavour to sustain me in dejection” (15). Writing these letters for his sister eases his feelings because it helps him forget about the time. Even though his crew can be considered as his companions, he is still longing for a friend who shares the same interests. Companionship is one of life’s necessities because humans are born to learn through interacting with other humans. Humans need someone to look after them not only when they’re lonely, but also when they are in need. An individual can influence others and can be influenced by others. These companions are here to guide you, see the good in you when you can’t, and motivate you to be the best version of yourself.
ReplyDeleteI agree, over time humankind has been conditioned to rely on companions. Walton's desperate need of a friend is evident due to his reaction to Victor Frankenstein. The way he describes him shows his excitement as well as satisfaction due to his need. Without companionship, human would not be able to function due to the fact that the majority of the things we learn from development is from wathcing others.
DeleteIs this mainly seen throughout the novel in the monster and in Victor? The novel shows how Victor is only nursed back to health as long as he has his friends and family around him. When he is all alone he is ill and full of despair because he can't seem to forget all that has happened to him. The monster is the same because he stalks a family in order to not feel lonely and actually have some sort of companionship. Although when he doesn't find it he feels all alone and he goes in search of his creator in a sense to find out why he abandoned him.
DeleteIn Letter 2, Walton expresses his need for a companion in the letter he writes to his sister Margaret stating " but I have one want which I have never yet been able to satisfy; and the absence of the object of which I now feel as a most severe evil. I have no friend, Margaret: when I am glowing with the enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy; if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavor to sustain me in dejection. I shall commit my thoughts to paper, it is true; but that is a poor medium for the communication of feeling. I desire the company of a man who could sympathize with me; whose eyes would reply to mine. You may deem me romantic, my dear sister, but I bitterly feel the want of a friend. I have no one near me, gentle yet courageous, possessed of a cultivated as well as of a capacious mind, whose tastes are like my own, to approve or amend my plans." Waltons need for a friend is so he can have someone to convey his thoughts with and in a way, to keep him sane as he is isolating himself from his friends and family. And in my opinion, companionship is one of life's necessity as we often need someone to vent to and express our thoughts and emotions. I feel as if without companionship one is left isolated with their own and thoughts that can drive them to insanity. Companionship is also important as without it, it leads to loneliness and depression. So yes, I believe companionship is one of life's necessity.
ReplyDeleteI somewhat agree with your position, I do not agree that humans need company for emotional reasons. Many people that have been in isolation for the majority of their lives, such as monks, still have their sanity as well other forms of venting. Humans need one another for survival and development. Many studies have shown that when one is isolated from the rest of society at a very early age, one is not able to function in society, resulting in them being useless. Through companionship, one learns basic life necessities that one needs to survive in today's society.
DeleteI do agree because we all need companionship to guide us through the way and help us out. It is through out Frankenstein in the novel, when Walton expresses when he is in need of a friend.
DeleteQuestion #2
ReplyDeleteIn his second letter, Walton writes to his sister saying, “I have no friend, Margaret: when I am glowing with the enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy; if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavor to sustain me in dejection.” Walton experiences loneliness in his journey, he’s not necessarily searching for interaction with others, he satisfies that need when he speaks to his crew. What Walton truly desires is the connection with someone who has the same interests as him. Mostly due to the fact, that if he achieves his goal, he wants to have someone around that appreciates what his accomplishment signifies. Before Walton meets Victor, he only has a crew that is just there to get the job done. They aren’t as invested as Walton, so if he discovers a passage near the pole or the secret to the compass, they won’t celebrate as much as him. Walton wants a companion that reassures that his success will leave a great impression on humankind forever. In my opinion, companionship is necessary for people. We seek out others because companionship allows us to have a place in which we can discuss our thoughts and feelings. It keeps us sane. There are examples in media that shows when a person is isolated for a long time from others for a while, they go a little bit insane. Company for day-to-day life isn’t needed, but in the long run, people do need the company of others once in a while.
I agree that humans should have a campanionship. Since we were born we seek campionship. We are given someone because we ourselves can't stand being alone. Yes we become insane and having company helps us find ourselves, where we stand. We need someone to lean on in the good times and bad times. When something happens in our lives, we seek for someone to be there to share that moment with. That's what Walton was seeking for, someone who would be there and understand him.
DeleteI respectfully disagree with your comment. Walton was searching for campanion and when he found Victor he was head over heels. Walton invested his time and resources into saving Victor. I would like to challenge your idea that we only need campanionship once in a while. People are always searching for company. Whether it is through social media, watching television, or a simple telephone conversation.
DeleteI agree that Walton really just wanted someone to make a connection with because he didn't need something physical, as seen as his relationship with his sister through which he confided in her his need for a companion that would share his enthusiasm for what he is doing, just in real time. And the fact that he can achieve this through letters shows that interaction does not need to be constant, even though his sister does not really full this role because Walton tells the reader that his sister believed the journey to be too dangerous.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI somewhat agree with your comment, Walton wasn't looking for someone to just leave a print of success on nor was he looking for validation when he said he had no friend. Of course, I will acknowledge that humans crave companionship and sometimes go as far as to say it is a necessity but Walton in this case was only looking for someone to accompany him and encourage his own eccentricities. To further explain, humans do look for someone with compatible tendancies but Walton already has that, his sister is his person. Margaret didn't agree with the trip but still offers her ear to listen. What Walton wanted was just a person to encourage his ambition.
Delete(Funnily enough, even Victor disagrees and tares down Walton's ambition).
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIn Letter 2, Walton writes to his sister and describes his need for companionship. Specifically, Walton states,” I have no friend, Margaret: when I am glowing with the enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy; if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavor to sustain my in dejection.” By stating this, the readers can conclude that Walton feels lonely and in a sense, desperate to find a friend he can share his successes with. In my opinion, I believe companionship is one of life’s necessities. I f humans didn’t keep themselves company, we would be segregated and probably even in conflict to survive. In addition, without companionship, one would often be sad and depressed. Yes, it is true that sometimes it’s better to be alone to have time to yourself; however, having someone by your side can affect you positively in many ways. For instance, having companionship can give you that extra push in succeeding and gaining confidence. Companionship is necessary because it allows for new discoveries to be made with the help of not just one person, but of many. Without companionship, the human race would become extinct because of the lack of reproduction.
ReplyDelete^^Paola Vergara
DeleteI totally agree with your statement because on letter 2 we see how desperate he is in need to find a companion to share his ideas with and someone who will support him. We as humans do need a companionship throughout our lives because without them we would be lost in this world. Having someone by your side helps you get through life and makes you feel like you have someone with you throughout your journey.
DeletePaola Vergara
DeleteP.2B
I completely agree with what you're saying . Humans are a very socially based species of organisms . If we were to be segregated we would only weaken ourselves . Our strength as a species comes from our numbers and our emotional attachment to each other , it fuels our ambitions and keeps us sane .
DeleteQuestion 2
ReplyDeleteIn Letter 2, Walton’s attitude is seen rather depressing, on the other hand, in Letter 1 he was full of passionate and a thrilled sailor. As he starts his letter, he states, “I have no friends, Margret: when I am glowing with enthusiasm of success...” The desire and need for a friend is shown dramatically. The loneliness he feels inside can’t be satisfy by anything around him. He blames his past for being “self-educated”, but more illiterate” in reality. He states that he has missed out on a great deal in terms of companionship. His companions have only been books for the twenty-eight years of his life. He wants a friend that will not approach him for being romantic but will "regulate his mind" instead. He is in a desire of a friendship or a companion that will encourage him and help him be successful to impress mankind. In my opinion, I feel that companionship is one of life’s necessities. We have been given a companion since we were born. Throughout the life, the need for a companion is there because we cannot stand being isolated. We will somehow seek someone because we are not use too being alone. Inside of us we have the need to seek companionship, because without it we wouldn’t find ourselves. Companionship helps us place ourselves where we stand.
I concur with you, when Walton met Frankenstein for the first time, he instantly saw him as someone he can celebrate his success with. Frankenstein became the friend Walton has been longing for due to the fact that they have the same aspirations in life, which is to “help” the mankind through their works. Having a companion is a basic human need because interacting is one of the most effective ways that help improve one’s knowledge. The connections a person develops with other people will have an effect on everyone that person will encounter, and this influence can impact a person in many ways.
DeleteI agree with both you and Cathleen on the point you brought up in "Letter 1". The reason being is that Walton feels alone and wants to tell someone about his experiences and successes and see them react to it rather then write a letter. And everyone has a companion whether it be human or animals like dogs it's just something every human needs.
DeleteI would like to challenge your ideas. What if Walton only wanted a companion because he wanted to brag? As we read the text we get a sense of overambition coming from Walton. Walton already had a crew to keep him company. Why search for company elsewhere?
DeleteRobert Walton believes that finding a passage to the North Pole will help mankind. Walton writes to his sister, Margaret Saville in England, ”But supposing all these conjectures to be false, you cannot contest the inestimable benefit which I shall confer on all mankind to the last generation, by discovering a passage near the pole to these countries”(Shelly 8). Walton feels that discovering such passage will be of great benefit to mankind. He also feels that those who risk their lives for discovery and exploration are almost God like. “Its production and features may be without example, as the phenomena of the heavenly bodies undoubtedly are in those undiscovered solitudes” (Shelly 8). In this particular quote he shares his feelings about how he sees, explorers such as himself, that go to uncharted territories in hopes of new discoveries.
ReplyDeleteI believe that humans should risk their lives for exploration. Without the risk and exploration we would not be where we are today in society. For example, The Lewis & Clark Expedition found a waterway to the Pacific Ocean. It met the Nez Pearce Indians and Sacagawea. It found and identified many species of animals and plants. And it discovered the terrain of the United States out to the west. Even though Lewis and Clark were greatly endangering their life by going on such an expedition, their risks have been one of the many milestones and contributions to the progress of society.
i totally agree with you that man should risk their life for exploration. these people dont only do it for fame but they do it because they also like their job.
DeleteI agree with you we should seek new adeventire. It will help us find ourself. What things we are missing from everything around us. Not being ordinary like others.
DeleteI agree with April, Christopher, and Jailim on the idea of exploration. It is what allows mankind to keep advancing in society. No one would ever really know what is out there if they do not go out and take risks.
DeleteI completely agree with mankind risking their lives to further explore the world.
DeleteIf people do not break boundaries then how would we break outside the box?
Besides, whether society is against something or not it, humanity's obstinate will to defy all rules prevails. There will always be the push that shatters the glass, the last marble before the bag bursts, even if humanity regrets the knowledge and wisdom they've obtained.
Examine “Letter 1,” and explain Robert Walton’s feelings about and motivations for going beyond the boundaries of what is known. Please use at least two text references in the course of your answer. Do you believe humans should risk their lives and those of others for exploration?
ReplyDeleteRobert Walton's feelings about motivations for going beyond the boundaries of what is known are quite childish. Though I mean this in a non negative manner but more of the way children see heroes and things that fascinate them. For example, in the book he compares his joy to that of a child, stating "to induce to commence this laborious voyage with the joy a child feels when he embarks in a little boat with his holiday mates." This has a deeper meaning since it is stated in letter one that he had no education, stating "My education was neglected." Moreover you can now see how his interest about going beyond the boundaries of what is known can be seen as normal. He isn't just acting abnormally but simply put he is trying to fill in the hole within himself since he was never taught. Though in my own opinion humans should not risk their lives and those of others for exploration. Sure the thrill of going to a place unknown to us seems like an exciting tale, however no one should go through various troubles to do so unless said trip was someone's long awaited dream such as Robert Walton. In this case Walton has been waiting for this opportunity and in the way he has deprived himself of rest, food, and sleep. If anything I would be interested to go in a great exploration with some good friends but I would not put someone's life before my own for it.
i disagree with you Jordon, i think man should risk their life for exploration and for what they like to do. with out people risking their life for exploration the whole america wouldn't exist right now. we wouldn't have mexico or the u.s if explores didn't risk their life to help develop a better world. this is exactly what Walton is doing he is trying to build a better world
DeleteThat is some fascinating insight CJ, but I believe that Jordan makes a good point in saying that Walton is being a bit childish. Ask yourself: "does he really want to go out and explore for the greater good of mankind? Or does he just want to, as Jordan said, "fill a hole"?
DeleteThat is an interesting point you make Darynne. Originally I believed that Frankenstein wanted to explore for the greater good but however, looking over the text again, it does seem that he just wants to do this for himself. To make his sister, Ms Saville, and all the other people who thought he was insane for going on such a quest that he can do it. That he can find a passage to the North Pole, he wants to prove himself right.
DeleteCristina Chinchilla
ReplyDeleteQuestion #2
In letter 2, Walton emphasizes to his sister the need of companionship and having someone who listens to his thoughts and feelings on his voyage. He feels as If he's alone on his voyage even though there's men to accompany him on his mission. Walton needs a companion who is similar to him in the aspect of his ambition and knowledge, also sharing sympathy among his desired companion. Walton states “I desire the company of a man who could sympathize with me; whose eyes would reply to mine. You may deem me romantic, my dear sister, but I bitterly feel the want of a friend. I have no one near me, gentle yet courageous, possessed of a cultivated as well as of a capacious mind, whose taste are like my own, to approve or amend my plans.” I believe that Walton needs reassurance of his plans and because of this he seeks a companion that will approve of his thoughts thus wanting a replica of himself, we can conclude this when he states that he wants someone with the same knowledge of his own. In my opinion, I believe that companionship is not part of life's necessity. It may be true that an individual may feel lonely when not having a companion, but it is not part of survival. Some people may become accustomed to not having a companion therefore, a companion is not essential in their lives. The idea of a friend or a companion has been strongly input in society that people have come to believe that it is a necessity. I believe it is the idea of companionship makes an individual desire the need for its presence rather than the necessity of having a companion.
Claudia Gamboa
ReplyDeleteQuestion 4
In letter 4 Walton is writing to his sister about his journey to the North Pole. Walton is ambitous to find a passage near the North Pole that the first sight of a human or living creation only makes him increase in ambition. Not only is ambitio shown in Walton, but it is also seen when Frankenstein. Frankenstein is endlessy searching for the monster, so much so that Walton's crew found Frankenstein on an ice berg clinging to life. On his journey in the sea Walton is searching for a companion. When he finds Frankenstein he immediatley puts all his resources to help him survive. "... I should have been happy to havenpossessed as the brother of my heart." Walton has been in need of a companion that this stranger instantly warmed up to Walton without even being consious. Walton also becomes unreliable because he has taken sympathy towards Frankenstein. Walton tries to justify Frankenstein actions by saying, "Even broken in spirit as he is, no one can feel more deeply than he does the beauties of nature." Which we have seen to be ironic because Frankenstein has only tried to alter nature by bringing life upon a creature.
In my opinion, your response seems a bit superficial. Your analysis only recounts events in the fourth letter that have to do with ambition and companionship. It doesn't really observe what the author is saying about these topics.
DeleteI like the approach you are taking with this blog. I haven't thought much about what Frankenstein really is, a hypocrite . He does everything in his power to create something unnatural , he steals from graves and doesn't some very very dirty work just to make something he hates in the end . After that uses nature to heal himself with his mental illness . Interesting to think about .
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteTo Walton a companion is something or someone he needs to fulfil the whole in his life. Throughout his voyage he realizes his hunger for someone to experience it with. In letter two, Walton says to Marget, “I have no friend, Marget: when I am glowing with enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy; if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavor to sustain me in dejection.”(12) With that being said, it proves how important it is for Walton to have someone to experience with. He questions himself because he is barely realizing that at the end of his voyage, he, alone, will either celebrate for his success or drown in disappointment. I believe one way he comforts himself is by speaking of his old lieutenant and how he was of help to him. In my opinion, companionship is not of life’s necessities because every person is different and not all are in need of one. We as humans are able to create our own happiness and comforts ourselves. Do not get me wrong, there are some people that do need a companion and without one, they are lost and lonesome. We can survive without a companion.
ReplyDeleteRobert Walton's feelings and motivation of going beyond the unknown is his ardent curiosity and his enthusiasm for achieving his satisfaction. Walton is an explorer and one of the things that an explorer always feels is curiosity. Walton felt the urge to explore the North Pole so he gathered a crew and sailed off on a voyage. What he thought he would accomplished by doing this is the recognition of discovering what has not been discovered before. A quote that shows his fancy in wanting to be recognized is when he states, "I shall satiate my ardent curiosity with the sight of a part of the world never before visited, and may tread a land never before imprinted by the foot of man". These feelings are what motivates his enthusiasm to push his mindset in exploring the unknown. A quote in which Walton expresses his emotions is when he states, "The reflections have dispelled the agitation with which I began my letter, and I feel my heart glow with an enthusiasm which elevates me to heaven". Walton's expedition released an abundance of his numerous feelings and motivation about advancing past the borderline of The unrevealed. These feelings have such amazing quality and should always be in the hearts of people. Which leads me to my belief in risking humans lives. I believe that people should risk theirs or others lives in exploring because that's what formulated the United States, Cuba, Mexico, Brazil. All these great nations achieved by exploration. Now Earth is a gargantuan planet made up of resourceful lands. If we were restrict ourselves from these other resources that could benefit and save us to survive. Then we'd obviously be consolidated and die off eventually. To explore is to gain and by exploring we gain the resources and that is essential to the virtues of surviving in this world. So yes I do believe that we should explore even though it means risking yourself or the lives of others.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you because everyone needs to be able to go out and explore because they all have curiosity in them. And if no one goes out to explore the world then we'll never know what's out there even if it means risking their lives. We won't know what dangers could be out there.
DeleteI agree with you for the reason that I believe people who are willing to, should risk their lives for exploration. Through the desire to know more about the unknown, countries have came about. Curiosity has given humankind a chance at survival. Whether it is through the discovery of medicine, land or new technology, they all been a significant contribution to mankind.
DeleteIn letter 2, Walton writes to his dear sister Margaret. Walton writes to her that he is in need of a companion. Although he has the lieutenant and other crew members to choose from, they are simply not suffice. He longs for someone who shares the same interests and ambitions as he does. In his letter, Walton writes, “I shall commit my thought to paper, it is true; but that is a poor medium for the communication of feeling. I desire the company of a man who could sympathize with me; whose eyes would reply to mine. You may deem me romantic, my dear sister, but I bitterly feel the want of a friend” (Shelley 12-13). With this being said, Walton believes companionship is one of life’s necessities. I on the other hand disagree. Every person is different. We can learn to survive without one with surrounding resources. Not to mention that these letters were written during a romantic era. An era that was about taking risks, adventure, and powerful emotions. If Walton did not need a companion and in the end he was successful, he could be proud of everything he accomplished without someone there by his side. All in all, some people enjoy being alone, while others like Walton need someone by their side. It all just depends on the person and how they feel about companionship.
ReplyDeleteI would like to disagree and say that I think companionship is essential to human life. If humans lived lives of solitude, interactions that teach us lessons would never exist. Companions can teach us things we don't know ourselves. A current example could be asking your friend what was for homework. If you had no companion you would be clueless about what tasks to do. Secondly, companionship gives you the chance to form a bond with someone else. The emotions created are objects that can't be replicated alone.
DeleteI would have to somewhat disagree because I believe that humans are social by nature and desire to be around certain people that they feel comfortable with, although I agree that some people don't need to be around others as often as other people because everyone is different.
DeleteI would have to somewhat disagree because I believe that humans are social by nature and desire to be around certain people that they feel comfortable with, although I agree that some people don't need to be around others as often as other people because everyone is different.
DeleteQuestion 1.
ReplyDeleteIn letter 1, Robert Walton explains his reasons for going on to further boundaries and he wants to go out and explore and discover great things. He says that it gives him excitement. "I may there discover the wondrous power which attracts the needle: and may regulate a thousand celestial observations, that require only this voyage to render their seeming eccentricities consistent for ever" Also he quotes, "I have no ambition to lose my life on the post-road between St. Peters-burgh and Archangel". Humans should risks there lives for exploration because they should be able to see whats there and if things don't work out then people will learn what not to do and study and how to fix it.
I would agree with you to a certain extent. I would agree that exploration is important since its mostly the cause on how we are here today, however most expeditions can be risky some resulting in horrible consequences such as death.
DeleteQuestion #2:
ReplyDeleteIn Letter 2, Walton feels the need for a companion because although he has had many jobs aboard different vessels on his journey to the North Pole, Walton hasn’t connected with anyone. And even with the men that Walton feels he can depend on, he wishes he had someone to express his feelings with and had similar likes. Walton expresses this saying, “I desire the company of a man who could sympathize with me; whose eyes would reply to mine,” and “ I have no one near me, gentle yet courageous, possessed of a cultivated as well as of a capacious mind, whose tastes are like my own, to approve or amend my plans.” I believe that companionship is one of life’s necessities as we as a species are social. We find comfort in one who we can share the things we are excited about and feel the need to validate the things we like to do. We pass ideas pass one another and Walton believes that the lack of a companion feels “as a most severe evil”. Of course one can become accustomed to being without a companion but that’s if the person has been without one for an extended amount of time, but once you have observed or have had the taste of what it’s like to have a friend, you can’t imagine a life all alone.
I agree that everyone needs someone in their life. It's a common belief that humans are by nature social animals. Because of this acceptance many ideas were created saying that humans need others to survive and that we are constantly ready for social interaction.
DeleteYou make a strong point, Walton has a need for someone who understands him greatly, which is how Victor can play that role or a companion. Though later on I feel as if Victor plays more of a person who is warning Walton of what he is doing instead of being a friend.
DeleteEntries after 4 pm will not receive credit (20pts)
ReplyDeleteB-day students due date is 1/12 by 4pm
DeleteA-day students due date is 1/13 by 4pm
In the first letter that Walton sends his sister a description of his idea of the voyage on which he wants to embark on. He wants to find the magic of the pole as he mentions, "There, Margaret, the sun is for ever visible; it's broad disk just skirting the horizon, and diffusing a perpetual splendour." In this phrase Walton gives an understanding that he is in search of a place with unknown beauty so he can find a new beginning that he has discovered on his very own to prove certain people wrong and so it will bring him glory. Walton has an ambition to become someone famous that can secure his name for years to come. This is shown when he states, " I also became a poet, and for one year lived in a paradise of my own creation; I imagined that I also might obtain a niche in the temple where the names of Homer and Shakespeare are consecrated." This quote proves how Walton was full of ambition on becoming a famous figure at one point or another of his life. It still doesn't make it okay for him to risk the lives of other just for his own ambitions and search for glory. The letter sent by Walton helps foreshadow how later in the story a character will putting everything at risk with there experimentation of some sort. This being a sub plot showing how the ambition of knowledge and discovery can lead to the life's of other being put at risk.
ReplyDeleteIn "Letter 4" as Walton has encountered this stranger that they had found at sea, raised a few red flags for myself. Surrounded by ice on their ship, stuck in place, Walton sees a figure in the distance. And this figure, as he later realizes, is a man. A man who was accompanied by dogs who were controlled by this man. As Walton began to see the man, I began to realize that it was a figment of his imagination. "And my own mind began to grow watchful with anxious thoughts," on a ship with nothing but comrades for months or even years at a time, the mind begins to play tricks on itself. And while Walton continues to explain this figure in his letter, it was clear that the crew on the ship as well could see the man figure. And as they began to help the frozen, almost dead man on board, Walton felt allured to the un-named man as he looked after him. Walton expressed the man as "attentively", "interesting", and "creature". As he was intrigued by the man, he felt as if the man was some type of experiment he created. Someone who would listen to Walton and seem actually interested in what he was speaking about. It wasn't until the man could actually speak with Walton that Walton was engrossed with his new comrade. "I never saw a more interesting creature: his eyes have generally an expression of wildness, and even madness, but there are moments when, if any one performs an act of kindness towards him or does him any the most trifling service, his whole countenance is lighted up, as it were, with a beam of benevolence and sweetness that I never saw equalled." Walton was looking for this acquaintance that kept him interested and made him feel as if he's not alone on his travels. And as time began to pass, Walton found his brother that he can cherish and share his compassion with. "For my own part, I begin to love him as a brother; and his constant and deep grief fills me with sympathy and compassion."
ReplyDeleteDo you think that Robert Walton is intrigued by Victor because he sees himself in him? They were both overly ambitious and both sought to do what "wrong" may Robert be describing himself using Victor?
DeleteIn the fourth letter Robert Walton addresses how ambition leads to the curiosity of new findings, but unfortunately the constant wanting to have knowledge can leave one alone and isolated or that the knowledge you were looking for isn't what is expected. He also states how being accompanied by a person can give a lot of joy and cause a person to relate to one another whether it is a from similarities or differences. Robert Walton lost a lot of friends in his life because of wanting to be a part of something that inspired him. An example of ambition in the text was on page 13,"You seek for knowledge and wisdom, as i once did; and i ardently hope that the gratification of your wishes may not be a serpent to sting you, as mine as been."Meaning that being ambitious isn't a bad thing ,but when you fail after spending years of your life giving up time with loved ones and friends you will be filled with regret.An example of companionship was on page 11," My affection for my guest increases everyday. He excites at once my admiration and my pity to an astonishing degree. How can i see so noble a creature destroyed by misery, without feeling the most poignant grief?He is so gentle, yet so wise; his mind is so cultivated, and when he speaks, although his words are culled with the choicest art, yet they flow with rapidly and unparalleled eloquence." Robert Walton shows that sometimes brain intelligence is't something everyone can acquire, instead he wishes to have the experiences and friendship that most people have, to connect with another person. He admires the man for it and wishes to have qualities he has that he does not.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteIn letter 2, Walton is a very lonely man on his journey to discover a route to the north pole. He sees that a companion is necessary to survive such a rigorous task. This task could be hurtful to the mind and the body, for that reason he uses Victor. Victor Frankenstein is the means of Walton’s cure for loneliness. Frankenstein and Walton both carry an intellect to compare and build off each other’s interest and passions. They both share the passion of discovery, adventure and praise but they are more different than they are the same. While Walton’s discovery contributes to humanity, Frankenstein’s causes grief, especially to his own life.
I believe that a companion is one of life’s greatest necessities. Our whole life we search for two companions, a best friend and a lover. Sometimes both of these positions are satisfied by one person. A best friend is often static and is someone from early childhood that stays until death. A lover is dynamic, they are constantly changing or out of fate are constantly lost. In Victor’s life he carries the same fate as his wife is killed by the monster. Instead of love acting as the rebirthing phoenix, it is lost to victor forever.
I really admire what you wrote about companionship and sometimes there are those who find both a best friend and lover in one person. I agree that at this point, Walton is willing to take in anyone that'll serve him as a friend and fill the void of loneliness that he feels.
DeleteQuestion#2:
ReplyDeleteIn letter #2 expresses his desperate need for a companion to his sister Margaret. Not feeling satisfied with the crewmen around him, Walton describes his frustration of having yet to find a companion and his idea of what a great companion would be like when he writes, "You may deem me romantic, my dear sister, but I bitterly feel the want of a friend. I have no one near me, gentle yet courageous, possessed of a cultivated as well as capacious mind, whose tastes are like my own to approve or amend my plans."(4) Walton's desire to make a connection with someone is understandable, however I do not agree with his idea of what a companion should be like. I believe that a companion should understand and support a person with their goals but a person shouldn't heavily rely on a companion in order to achieve their life goals. Walton has this unrealistic built into his mind of finding a companion that he has made himself believe that once he does find one he will finally feel satisfied.
Question #1
ReplyDeleteIn the first letter Robert Walton has a sense of curiosity and ambition as he explains how the "unexplored regions" make him feel the need to explore and discover something his pre-descendants have not. For example, Walton gives an idea of what he specifically seems to be looking for as he states, "i may there discover the wondrous power which attracts the needle,and may regulate a thousand celestial observations", and that line itself can explain his curiosity and will to figure out a mystery which was relevant in that time era. Throughout the first letter he continues to show his motivation and will for success by claiming to give up riches in order to achieve his goal. Walton makes that claim by saying "My life may have been passed in ease and luxury but oh i preferred glory to every enticement wealth could placed in my path." which shows determination to what he wishes to unfold or discover. I personally do believe humans should risk their life for exploration to a certain extent. If we as humans do not go beyond our own strengths and intelligence, the following generations will have nothing to follow up on such as inventions and other significant foundations.
do you think that maybe ambition was the main cause of everything they accomplished or was it driven by something deeper?
DeleteQuestion #2
ReplyDeleteIn letter 2, Walton writes to his sister telling her that throughout this journey he has no friends. Although he is on this journey with a crew, he has not yet found a friend whom he is able to bind with things he is passionate about. Walton writes, "I have no friend, Margaret: when I am glowing with enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy: if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavor to sustain my dejection," he realizes that he lacks as an individual since he hasn't been able to find this companion. Adding on he says, “I desire the company of a man who could sympathize with me; whose eyes would to mine,” he wants someone who able to share his passion. Walton wants someone who will support his decisions without his companion doubting him yet he hasn’t found that person causing him to be lonely through his journey. In my opinion, companionship is one of life’s necessities because one needs a person to go to. Someone who will make them believe in their selves and someone who is capable of making that person happy. Having a companion throughout your life makes your journey a bit easier and bit more adventurous than doing everything on your own.
Good points on the use of feelings and passions. Description of what Walton needed and felt towards his passions and desires.
DeleteI completely agree. I believe that there are many key factors that allow one to reach success, one being a companion. In Walton's case, he felt that he needed someone to talk to about his voyage, someone who can possibly help him or judge his undertakings. This goes to show that mankind cannot always do everything on their own and therefore, companions are one of life's necessities.
DeleteThe stranger found by Walton needed assistance and was alone. The stranger refused to go with Walton even if he was emaciated, weak, and starving. Then Walton told the stranger that he was heading north and that's when the stranger agreed to broad his ship. The stranger took a while to recover and once he did no one asked him questions, so he wouldn't be so overwhelmed to remember. With this the stranger and Walton started to become really close, so Walton decided to tell him his story. The stranger to me seemed scared maybe even traumatized. The way Walton found him makes me think exactly that, he was running away from something or was terrified of something. Walton found him emaciated as said, to explain the stranger's state in health. To explain his physical apprence, so the reader understands that the stranger needs the help. When the word weak was used, he referred too as what he saw in his physical and mental appearance. The stranger could not understand or wanted to go else where. Straving is once more to add to his physical and mental appearance, of how he is not functioning, because the need of nutritious in his system.
ReplyDeleteMoe Robles
ReplyDeletein letter four Walton reveals a strong yearning for accomplishment and companionship. His keen thirst for a friend who shares his same ambitious mentality is only quenched after rescuing Victor Frankenstein. Immediately after meeting Victor, Robert shows an incredible admiration for him when he says, "he is a noble man in his better days, being even now so attractive and amiable." This language can be interpreted in many ways, but in regards to how people would speak of others in the 19th century, this simply shoes Walton was fond and excited for a potential friendship with the man he saved. Perhaps because of their similar ambitions to stretch the bounds of scientific discovery did Walton immediately become attached to Frankenstein.
Question 4
ReplyDeleteThroughout the forth letter Walton is very excited to be blessed with Victor's presence. To Walton, Victor is a hail mary in his search for a companion who would ardently advocate to expand an enterprise by any means necessary when he says, " I was easily led by the sympathy which he evinced, to use the language of my hear... How gladly I would sacrifice my fortune, my existence, my every hope to the furtherance of my enterprise." Victor may have indicated that he shared such extreme passion however the horror he feels towards it was too much to bare. Walton respects Victor, much like a brother "For my own part, I begin to love him as a brother" and perhaps this friendship and ambition could be shared but Victor would rather steer Walton far away from this path of stretching the limits of man's power. Victor suddenly bursts out "-Unhappy man! Do you share my madness? Have you drunk also of the intoxicating draught?" This violent opposition for being a slave of passion and inspiration strikes Walton's curiosity and even leads to small bits of self reflection.
Throughout this letter the two seem to hit a point in which Victor begins to protect his dear friend. Victor goes so far as to compare knowledge to this extent that of a serpent and even stops Walton from further trying to interrupt his idea that being so wise ruins everything. Ambition during this letter is less of a positive but a dangerous slope that could soon be destructive if both people try to fix and perfect the goals of each other. Friendship is what saves a pair because like Victor displayed, friends are their to stop you before you get over your head and at the very least warn you of what's to come.
In Letter 2, Walton is at sea among the crew longing for companionship. Writing letters to his sister helps to ease the loneliness somewhat, but still desires friendship. Although he has considered the captain and lieutenant as possible choices as his companions, neither seems to fulfill that role for him. He yearns for someone like himself to pass the time. As we read on, Walton’s desire for a companion later reflects the monsters need for a companion. He mentions his desire for a companion, by saying, "I greatly need a friend who would have sense enough not to despise me as romantic, and affection enough for me to endeavour to regulate my mind." A Romantic notion is that Walton is so open to finding a friend and showing his feelings.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, companionship is a necessity of life. Interaction with others is a part of life, those people can influence, encourage, and push you to your limits. Companionship isn’t just a friendship, it’s about having someone you can relate to, to trust, to love. Someone to enjoy their company. Talking to people keeps us mentally healthy, and keeps things in perspective. The more we talk to each other, the more reasonable we become. It helps to keep us sane.
In letter 2 Walton is still continuing his trip to the north pole. In this letter Walton is explaining to his sister how he already has found sailors, That he can depend but its not the same trust as if he had some one who had the same passage for example he writes"When I am glowing with the enthusiasm of success there will be non to participate my joy..." He is stating that with the sailors they dont get as excited as him when it comes to his discoveries, so if he had someone that would get as exited as him. You can also scene the frustration that he faces when its just him .When Victor came came along he found that sense of happiness and joy since they had that same interest. So when one of they made a discovery they both got exited.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteQuestion 2
ReplyDeleteIn letter 2, Walton writes to his sister explaining how he has found sailors and that he will venture off to his journeys for new discoveries. Briefly, he tells his sister of his wants and desire for a companionship. Walton feels as if he could never satisfy this specific longing. " You my deem me romantic, my dear sister, but I bitterly feel the want of a friend." Walton craves for this because he wants someone who is like himself; someone who will "approve or amend" his plans, someone who sympathizes with him, and "whose eyes would reply to" him. I believe it is in fact one of life's essential necessities to develop friendships and relations with others. Although, companionship is not viewed as important to some, it still has a huge effect to a person's life. To some who do not have human relations with others, loneliness occurs which may feel permanent. Without companionship, pain and sadness may sever trust in others which makes it difficult to depend on future friendships. By having companions, we learn to see and view new possibilities by contrasting our own perspectives with others. It creates new options when having connections among other people that are not available to someone who is isolated and alone. A lifetime of ideas, curiosity of everything and everyone, challenges, interactions, and relationships is a effect from connecting with others that we grow to develop our own personalities, our own values, and our own morals.
i agree with you that companionship is a essential part of human life. if humans never had championship then we wouldn't have life. animal themselves have companionship. i also agree that with companionship we get our personalities,value, and morals.
DeleteIn "Letter 2", Walton begins to collect the things he needs to embark on his journey to the North Pole. Although, he has most of what he needs to be successful on his journey, he yearns for a true companionship to fill this want, he has not yet satisfied. I believe Walton wants a friend to share his enthusiasm to, someone who will help him out through his failures, and someone who shares the same interests as himself. This longing for a friend is shown while he explains to his sister, "I desire the company of a man who could sympathize with me; whose eyes would reply to me...my dear sister, but I bitterly feel the want of a friend,". This quote highlights how Walton's loneliness influences his longing for companionship to communicate his feelings with, rather than "committing his thoughts to paper,".
ReplyDeleteI believe that companionship is not one of life's necessities, just because without a companion, a person would still be able to survive. However, I do believe that companionship helps us figure out our purpose of life or our journey into the world. A companionship is someone who can support, encourage, influence, or listen to you when you encounter life obstacles, successes, or failures. It is when have someone who understands you or can relate to you more than anyone else could, which makes people feel accepted or important. Although, I believe it is not a necessity for life, I believe that it helps people to express their true feelings through their interaction with a companion.
I concur with what you said when saying that we humans, do not need a companion to survive. I believe a companion is more of a luxury than a nessicity. We can still live life, be successful and be happy without a companion. Although, I understand it would be "nice" to have that person to share it with. However it is not a nessicity.
DeleteI want to respectfully disagree with your opinion about a companion not being a necessity in life. I believe that having someone in your life, whether it's a friend, family member, or boyfriend/girlfriend,is a necessity. I mean think about it. If we had no one to share our successes with or not a shoulder to cry on, our lives would be miserable and we'd be completely clueless. I feel that we humans need a special someone in our lives in order to avoid living a lonely and depressed life.
DeleteQuestion #3 Raul Martinez Jr.
ReplyDeleteThe stranger to me seems a bit like a mysterious and suspicious character. It is quite strange the circumstances of his rescue where he was found, especially since it was in such a desolate tundra. Also, the day before he was found, Captain Walton's men spotted a sledge drawn by dogs with a giant at its helm. The next day they find the stranger when "a sledge, like that [they] had seen before, which drifted towards [them] in the night, on a large fragment of ice." The sledge was found with only one dog remaining alive and with a weary man within it. What is more strange to me about this stranger is that he would not readily accept rescue without asking where the Captain was heading. If I was the Captain, I would be a bit suspicious as to how he got himself in that situation and if he is to bring the same fate of being stranded on the ice to me and my men. But once the man is aboard, Walton describes the stranger as a amicable man but with a lingering sadness behind his thoughts. He is also described as an intellectual type which gives me the impression that he may have trying to do something equally as dangerous for the quest for knowledge, much like Captain Walton. But this impression changes when the stranger explains that he has had his life plagued with misfortune. With this, I feel as if the stranger may be one who is trying to flee from his problems or that he is out looking for solutions because that is the nature of an intellectual.
In "Letter 1" of the novel, Robert Walton expresses to his sister his optimistic attitude and fame-motivated reasoning for going on the exploration. He confesses that "inspirited by this wind of promise, [his] day dreams become more fervent and vivid" (1). This certainty personalizes Walton as a very self-assured character when it comes to believing in himself. He sets high hopes for himself and doesn't limit his dreams very much, including his dream to be glorified due to this exploration. He proudly admits to his sister "you cannot contest the inestimable benefit which I shall confer on all mankind to the last generation" by going on this voyage (2). Walton's explicit idea of his future holds him at a point of arrogance to the reader. He most likely will benefit mankind, but his attitude is making him unbearable. In my opinion, I believe it is perfectly fine for people to risk their lives for exploration as long as they are aware of what could happen. Some people yearn for adventure and in that, they could also discover benefits for humanity; it's technically a "win-win scenario" for everybody. If it weren't for explorers, we wouldn't be in the places we are today.
ReplyDeleteIn "letter 2" from the novel Frankenstein, Walton feels the need of having a friend by him side to express how he feels and to have someone to share his emotions with. Walton says, "... when I'm glowing with the enthusiasm of success, there will be none to participate my joy; if I am assailed by disappointment, no one will endeavor to sustain me in dejection". Walton at the moment does not have anyone to share how excited he is to express the success he has done. In my opinion I do feel we need a companion to be there by our side to share the events that have gone on and to have someone by your side to cry on when you go through a tough time. Having a companion
ReplyDeleteisn't just someone who is there by your side but also someone who understands you and knows how you are doing. When you had a bad day or good your friend will know how to make you feel better and understand the way you feel. Referring back to Walton, he feels having a companion could make a him feel better for himself. He would have someone to be happy or sad with and someone he can be himself self with.
I respectfully somewhat disagree with you when saying you need a companion by your side. I believe a companion is not a nessicity we all need, however I think it depends on the person. Some people do actually need that person because without him or her, he or she can become depressed. On the other hand, there are others who do not need that companion to survive. He or she is able to live their life without one and is absolutely happy.
DeleteI strongly agree with you because whenever something good happens to you or you experience something so wonderful, you want to have someone by your side to experience the same thing. Same goes for if you're upset or have just endured something tragic, you want to have someone there by your side to console you.
ReplyDeleteWow! What great dialogue and discussion! I'm loving the insight and use of textual evidence. Good job.
ReplyDeleteIn letter 3, we see Victor, brimming with the joy and content of his journey back into the costal lines of the Southern Gales. He's blinded by the allusion of fortunate safety, where his mind is set completely on the belief smooth sailings and complete obligement on his venture saying,"which blows us steadily towards those shores which I so ardently desire to attain-". Its these kinds of tone of voice in Frankenstein, that gives the reader a sense of comfort that later turns out to be either a foreshadowing of somesort or the intention to disprove one's perspective in the story as to what might happen next.
ReplyDeleteIn the novel Frankenstein by Mary Shelly the topic of having Natural beauty is repetitive. Take Elizabeth for example, when victor's father first sees her " a child fairer than a pictured cherub " (pg 17) he instantly agrees to keep her. Her beauty, not designed like the creatures, was created naturally. Thus, allowing the audience to perceive that most things created by artificial man-made design are unfavorable and a smear against all things natural. If it is not made by fate then it shouldn't be made at all would be a perfect theme for this topic.
ReplyDeleteThe creature exemplifies this because when victor first realizes who he has created he was flooded with indescribable emotions " How can I describe my emotions at this catastrophe.. " referring to his creature "... The wretch whom with such infinite pains.. I had endeavoured to form." (Pg35) immediately this brings more attention to the idea that having been born a pure being inherently makes one good while creating something of an accident and design will form an inherently evil being.
"The different accidents of life are not so changeable as the feelings of human nature." (Pg 35)
Blog #1
ReplyDeleteIn letter 1, Robert Walton sends a letter to her letter about his travel to a dangerous voyage in which the sister once said to Robert that he will not find success in this voyage. He later then send a letter to her saying that he will find success in this voyage, leading to his reaction to the sisters words. Robert Walton time towards this is sophisticate in which he doesn't brag or shove it at her face. He just tells her humbly that he will find succes in this voyage, that he will become a strong power man in history. Word in which used were "wondeous power" that he will find. He was determined to find success and the only reason he didn't fail was his determination. Furthermore, going through hard difficulty voyage to find succes is not something that should be done often. A person should be patient and wait for the right moments and analysis the lands. In order to not lose live in this voyage and also safes you from feeling guilty.
Adrian Trigo Question 1:
ReplyDeleteIn the book "Frakenstein" by Mary Shelley we read a letter from a character named Robert Walton to his sister where he describes his very ambitious trip to the North Pole which at the time has never been done before."... When shall i return? Ah, dear sister, how can i answer this question? if i succeed, many, many months, perhaps years, will pass before you and i may meet." This is one of Walton's last lines he write to his sister letting her know that this trip has the possibility of taking years. Not only does Walton let us know the length of this his trip is that of a huge commitment but he ends his letter by stating, "If i fail you will see me again soon, or never. " This where as a reader i began to question whether his search for glory is worth his life and the lives of his companions or if it is just selfish narcissism. When considering history and the normal cost of exploration being lives and many resources. I am stuck between supporting his trip because normally there is something new in these unexplored places that have resources we need but when you consider that Walton is going to a place where there is just ice , i find the cost of death way too much of a gamble for some fame and glory.
Blog #2
ReplyDeleteIn the novel, "Frankenstein" by Mary Shelley we see the Victor is troubled with the burden of having to have ever created the creature. Through his contemplations, he is travelinh throughout Europe and the other parts of the world for the sole purpose of experimentation. He envelopes a fear that he has been followed by the monster throughout his venture, stalking him and not letting him out of his sights. Its this presumption, that was caused by the creature vengance on Victor for destroying his possible/soon to be counterpart who he would then live its life with, but with Victors sketical view of point. He saw that the creature's partner could possibly backfire on him, the creature and the compromise they had made if Victor were to create the creature a companion. Victor throughout the story is held down with anxiety, shame and spitefullness towards himself for ever creating the creature and putting his loved ones in danger.